You ask how they're feeling and get "fine." You ask again a day later, more gently, and get "I don't know." You try the bigger version ("I feel like you never let me in") and they go quiet, pick up their phone, or find something urgent to do in the kitchen.
If this sounds familiar, you're not wrong to want to know what's going on inside the person you share a life with. But the way the asking has been going may be making it harder for them to answer.
Quick Answer
When a partner won't talk about feelings, pushing harder usually makes them pull back further. This loop is often called the pursue-withdraw pattern. What helps is making it easier to open up: start gently, ask about one small, specific thing, give them time to answer, agree on a break if either of you gets overwhelmed, and respond warmly to whatever they do share. You can't make someone open up, but you can change what they're opening up to.
Want to work through your own version of this?
TL;DR
- A partner who shuts down when feelings come up is often overwhelmed rather than indifferent. The more you push, the more they retreat, and each move makes the other's worse.
- Who pushes and who withdraws isn't fixed by gender. In a 2010 study of straight, gay and lesbian couples, the partner who wanted more change tended to push.
- Small, specific and low-pressure works better than "we need to talk about us": one question about one moment, with time to answer.
- When your partner does share something, how you respond decides whether they try again.
- If the withdrawal comes with control, threats or fear, it's a safety issue, and a professional or a crisis line is the right place to start.
Why does my partner shut down when I want to talk about feelings?
Most of the time, the shutting down is a response to how the conversation feels from their side.
For some people, a feelings conversation arrives like an exam they didn't study for. They don't have the words ready, they suspect any answer will be the wrong one, and the quickest way to make the pressure stop is "I'm fine" or silence. From your side, that silence reads as rejection, so you push a bit harder. The harder push makes the exam feel higher-stakes, so the silence gets deeper. You're both trying to feel safe, in opposite directions.
The loop goes by a few names: pursue-withdraw, pursuer-distancer, or demand-withdraw in the research. Sue Johnson, who developed Emotionally Focused Therapy, described it in an interview as "the most classic dance of relationship distress," with one partner escalating and the other shutting down to make the fight stop. Her framing is the useful part: the dance is the problem, and both people are caught in it.
It also isn't a men-versus-women thing, whatever the jokes say. Sarah Holley, Virginia Sturm and Robert Levenson studied straight, gay and lesbian couples in 2010 and found the demand-withdraw pattern in every type of couple. The partner who wanted more change tended to demand, and the one who wanted less tended to withdraw. If you're the one asking to talk, that probably makes you the natural pursuer.
If the same push and pull shows up elsewhere too (one of you reaches for closeness under stress, the other needs space), our post on the anxious-avoidant dance covers the attachment side, and why being known feels so risky covers the rest.
Is my partner stonewalling, or are they flooded?
Stonewalling, in the Gottman Institute's terms, is when the listener withdraws from the conversation: tuning out, turning away, getting suddenly busy. It's one of the institute's Four Horsemen, and it often starts as a way out of a conversation that feels like it's getting more and more negative.
Flooding is what's often happening underneath. When someone is flooded, their body has gone into stress mode: a faster heart rate, stress hormones, fight-or-flight. A Gottman blog post on emotional flooding puts it bluntly: when you're flooded, you are "deaf to anything your partner says."
You can't talk someone out of being flooded, and pushing on usually turns a pause into a wall. What helps is a real break with a time to come back. The Gottman Institute recommends at least twenty minutes, because that's roughly how long it takes a body to calm down, spent on something soothing like a walk, music or slow breathing. Replaying the argument in your head doesn't count.
Try it: when you're both calm, agree on a signal for next time, something like "I'm flooded. I need twenty minutes, and then I'll come back." Then agree that the person who took the break is the one who restarts the conversation.
What should I say to get my partner to open up?
Aim for a conversation that's easy to say yes to. A few moves make that more likely.
Start soft. The Gottman Institute's gentle start-up means complaining without blame: say what you feel and what you need, with "I" instead of "you." "I've been missing hearing what's going on with you. Could we talk for ten minutes after dinner?" gets a different reception from "You never tell me anything."
Ask about one thing. "How do you feel about us?" is enormous. "What was the hardest part of your week?" or "How did it feel when your sister canceled on Sunday?" is answerable.
Give them time. Some people need to think before they know what they feel. "You don't have to answer now. Can we come back to it tomorrow?" takes the exam pressure off and gives a slower processor room to find an answer.
Offer words instead of a blank. "What are you feeling?" is a hard question if you don't have a ready vocabulary for it. Options are easier: "Was that more annoying, more hurtful, or just exhausting?" They can pick one, reject all three, or say "kind of the second one," and any of those is a start.
Jefferson Fisher, the trial lawyer behind The Next Conversation, goes a step further. He points out that not showing an emotion isn't the same as not feeling it, and suggests building that vocabulary together so the quiet partner isn't the project. His go-to opener is low-key on purpose: "What's coming up for you?" We pulled his phrases for moments like this into our review of The Next Conversation.
Try it: pick one small moment from this week and ask about it with a time limit: "Can I ask you about one thing from Tuesday? Five minutes, then we'll drop it." Then drop it at five minutes, even if it's going well, so the next ask is easy to say yes to.
What makes a partner shut down even more?
A few common moves make withdrawal more likely, even when they come from a good place:
- Bad timing. Bedtime, the moment they walk in the door, or the middle of a fight.
- Interrogation. A string of "but why?" and "what do you mean?" after a short answer.
- Labels. "You're so avoidant" turns a conversation into a verdict, and people defend themselves against verdicts.
- Punishing the small stuff. If a small admission gets a correction or a debate, the lesson is that opening up costs more than it's worth.
How should I respond when my partner does open up?
Partners who find feelings hard rarely open up in one big speech. It's usually something small: a sigh about work, an "I'm a bit wiped," half a sentence about their dad. The Gottman Institute calls these bids, defined as any attempt to get a partner's attention, affirmation, affection or other positive connection. In John Gottman's research with newlyweds, the couples still married six years later had turned toward each other's bids 86% of the time. The couples who divorced averaged 33%.
Turning toward a small disclosure can look like this:
- Ask one follow-up. Put the phone down and say "Wiped how? Busy, or something with someone?"
- Reflect before you fix. "That sounds like a lot to carry on your own" usually does more than three suggestions.
- Say thanks, lightly. "I like hearing this stuff." Keep it low-key, because a big reaction can make the next disclosure feel riskier.
Small admissions met with warmth give a partner a reason to make bigger ones. Our guide to emotional safety in relationships covers how that trust gets built over time.
Try it: for one week, treat every small bid from your partner as the conversation you've been asking for, and keep a rough count. You may find there were more of them than you'd been noticing.
What if I'm always the one who pursues?
Then you hold more of the leverage than it feels like. The psychologist Harriet Lerner, quoted on the Gottman blog, points out that the pursuer is usually the person more distressed by the distance, and so the one more motivated to change the pattern. Her suggestion is to call off the chase and find ways to reconnect without it. In practice that looks like:
- Saying it once, clearly. One clear request lands better than circling back to the same topic every day.
- Calming yourself first. Notice the anxious pull to reach for reassurance and give it a minute before you act on it.
- Naming the loop together. When you're both calm: "I think when I push, you go quiet, and when you go quiet, I push harder. Can we try something different?"
- Repairing quickly. When a conversation goes badly, reach back first instead of letting it sit for days. Our repair scripts and prompts have wording to start from.
When the pressure drops, some partners start to step forward on their own, though rarely on your timeline.
When is this more than a communication problem?
Better openers help most people who find feelings hard to talk about. Some situations need something else first.
- If the silence comes with control, threats or intimidation, or you feel afraid of your partner's reaction, this is a safety issue. Talk to a licensed professional or a domestic violence or crisis line. Find A Helpline lists free, confidential services in many countries, and in an emergency, contact your local emergency services.
- If the withdrawal is new and comes with changes in sleep, mood or interest in things they used to enjoy, it may be about more than the relationship, and a doctor or licensed professional is a better first stop than a feelings conversation.
- If you've changed how you ask, over months, and nothing moves, that's information too. Our post on what to do when a partner won't go to therapy or read the books covers what you can still do alone, and when to name the imbalance directly.
Growing Us is a coaching tool, not therapy, and it isn't the right place to start if there's abuse, a safety concern or a crisis.
Not sure what your first sentence should be?
FAQ
Why does my partner say "I don't know" when I ask how they feel?
Sometimes because it's true in the moment. Some people need time, or a specific example, before they can name what they feel, and a broad question under pressure makes that harder. Try a narrower question with options ("more annoyed, or more hurt?") and offer to come back to it later. "I don't know yet" is a different answer from "I don't want to tell you."
Is my partner stonewalling if they walk away during an argument?
It depends on whether they say they're coming back. Walking away with a plan to return is a break, and the Gottman Institute recommends breaks of at least twenty minutes when someone is flooded. Stonewalling is withdrawing without that signal: tuning out, going silent, or leaving with no word on when you'll talk again. A phrase like "I need twenty minutes, then I'll come find you" turns walking away into a break.
Can I work on this if my partner won't join in?
Yes. The moves in this post are yours to make alone, and they're free. If you'd like help planning or rehearsing the conversation, Growing Us works solo: you talk it through with the coach by voice or text first. It's free to start, with two coaching sessions and no credit card, then $1 a session (as of October 2026). It's available on Android, and on iPhone in the US, UK, Canada, New Zealand and Singapore.
You can't install openness in another person. What you can do is make the next conversation smaller, kinder and easier to come back to, and notice when they take a step toward you. A good first goal is a conversation your partner would be willing to have again next week.
Growing Us can help you find that first sentence and practice it before you say it out loud, on your own and at your own pace. If you'd like to see your own patterns first, start with the free Pulse Check, no partner required.